 |
Tornado Spinning
|
 |
|
|
Welcome Teachers and Students
Visit
Our Archives
How to
Ask a Question
Ask
A Question
Question
of the Week
Our
Expert Scientists
About
Ask A Scientist
Referencing
NEWTON BBS Articles
Frequently Asked Questions |
Tornado Spinning
Question: Why do tornadoes turn in a counter-clockwise direction in the
northern hemisphere and clockwise in the southern hemisphere? Is it magnetic?
---------------------------------------
Not to complicate things, but I am reasonably sure that tornadoes
in the Northern Hemisphere have been observed to spin in both directions,
although one is more prevalent...
Mark Fernau
====================================================================
At least the great majority of tornadoes rotate counterclockwise
(as do all low-pressure systems) in the northern hemisphere, and clockwise in
the southern hemisphere, for the reason (coriolis force) given by Eric
Peterson in response #1. But occasionally, it would seem, northern hemisphere
tornadoes do rotate clockwise: S. Flora's book "Tornadoes of the United
States" cites an 1890 article in the American Meteorological Journal. Its
author, a J.P. Finley, states that, of 550 American tornadoes he studied, 29
were deemed to have rotated clockwise. I have not been able to find any
"modern" study of this question. But I believe it could be true. The region
of swirling air that contracts to become the tornado is not itself large
enough in extent to have its rotation dictated by the coriolis force; rather,
it "inherits" this tendency from the great masses of air whose movement sets
the stage for the storms and any associated tornadoes. If the study cited is
correct and representative, on occasion the direction of rotation is set by
some other factor, perhaps the topography in the area where the tornado forms,
for example.
Ronald Winther
====================================================================
The previous responses were correct in that the coriolis force is
the reason air circulates in a clockwise direction around high pressure and
counterclockwise around low pressure in the northern hemisphere. The coriolis
force can explain the rotation in large scale high and low pressure areas
including hurricanes. However, the rotation of a tornado is much more
complicated. Tornadoes in the northern hemisphere can rotate in either
direction but counterclockwise rotation is much more common. The rotation is
produced by wind shears and pressure forces in and near the parent
thunderstorm. Thunderstorms form when warm moist air rises rapidly upward.
This upward current of air within a thunderstorm is referred to as an updraft.
If sufficient vertical wind shear exists, this updraft will rotate. Vertical
wind shear is a change in wind speed and/or direction from the ground up
through the atmosphere. If the wind speed increases rapidly with height
and/or if the wind direction turns clockwise with height, air being drawn in
toward the thunderstorm updraft will develop a spin about the horizontal axis.
Think of an imaginary paddlewheel floating in the air. If winds blowing
across the top of the paddlewheel are stronger than the winds at the bottom of
the paddlewheel, it will spin. As the air rises into the updraft, the spin
about the horizontal axis becomes a spin about the vertical axis. Imagine if
you take a rope and roll it along the ground (it is spinning about the
horizontal). Now pick up the middle of the rope but keep rolling it. Now the
two dangling ends are spinning about the vertical. But one end is turning
clockwise and the other counterclockwise. Strong winds blowing through the
storm produce pressure forces within the storm that enhance or suppress the
updraft. Most tornadoes in the United States occur in the warm humid air mass
ahead of an approaching low pressure area. Because of the coriolis force,
winds usually turn clockwise with height. This wind profile enhances the
counterclockwise rotating updraft and suppresses the clockwise portion of the
updraft. That is why most tornadoes turn counterclockwise. However if winds
are from a nearly uniform direction throughout the depth of the storm, both
circulations can be maintained. In this case the storm can split producing
both a clockwise and anti-clockwise rotating tornadoes. This has been
documented with radar.
Jim Allsopp
====================================================================
|
|
We provide a means to have questions answered that are not going to be easily found on the web or within common references.
Return to NEWTON's HOME PAGE
For
assistance with NEWTON contact a System Operator, at Argonne's Division
of Educational Programs
NEWTON
BBS AND ASK A SCIENTIST Division of Educational Programs
Building
DEP/223 9700 S. Cass Ave. Argonne,
Illinois 60439-4845
USA
Last
Update:
April 2006
|