 |
Ask A Scientist©
Biology Archive
|
 |
If your mind were a computer
Author: fath
Text: In terms of computer memory how much information can the human
brain store? Similarly, what is the processing speed and architecture of the
brain?
Response #: 1 of 2
Author: James Murray
Text: Yours is a difficult question to answer, mainly because the human
brain is the most complicated object in the known universe. Consider that a
human brain contains some 100 billion neurons. And likely 500 billion or more
supporting cells. And each neuron is extremely complicated electrically.
Each neuron has millions of channels in its membrane and each of those
channels is a digital gate that can allow electrical current to pass. The
wiring diagram of a single neuron would be hopelessly complex. The simple
answer to your question is that nobody knows. Information storage is easily
defined in digital computers because one knows exactly how and where
information is stored. Not so with the brain. We know some about how and
where, but not enough to estimate how much information is up there in your 2
pound universe. Consider that if you know how to play baseball well, the
entire rules book is stored in your brain. And besides that, the ability to
hit a baseball with a bat is also stored in your brain (the cerebellum most
likely, although some simple information is stored in the spinal cord). Think
of all the face you would recognize. One would likely require 1000's of bits
of information to accomplish a single face recognition. Our brain's capacity
is vast, perhaps someone has tried to estimate its capacity, but I would guess
not, since we are so ignorant. Processing speed is also difficult to answer
and the tasks the brain processes are hard to quantify. Adding the digits 1
and 1 requires not only the ability to add, but the ability to recognize
shapes, contrasts and to remember that certain shapes represent numbers. Some
people are capable of doing mental calculations with the speed of some
computers. Although these people are rare, it is possible that all people are
capable of these feats with practice. You might recall the movie Rain Man
that portrayed a man who could remember cards so well he could win at gambling
often. As for architecture, here we know something, but certainly not enough.
The human brain is both serial and massively parallel in its processing
algorithms and in its structure. Each neurons sends out 100's of outputs to
many different neurons. And each neuron receives thousands of inputs. These
inputs are integrated in a complicated analog process involving synapses and
dendritic trees. Once integrated, that information is relayed to a "spike
initiation zone" where it is decided whether the neuron will send a digital
signal or not. The temporal pattern of those digital signals travels over
axons and cross long (inches or feet) distances in the nervous system. In
general, information flows from sensors, into integrating systems of neurons,
and then out to motor neurons and finally to effectors like muscles. I could
try to answer a more detailed question if you like. But as I said, mostly we
do not know much about the brain.
Response #: 2 of 2
Author: wizkid
Text: It is also interesting that most people may use less than 10% of
their neural capabilities. This figure was arrived at when head-trauma
patients required the removal of nearly 90% of their cerebrum, and yet
recovered and continued to lead normal, successful lives. Of course, this may
partly have been the result of the parallel capabilities of the brain,
overlapping and "making up" for what was lost. The closest computer
approximation of a brain are neural networks. These are a general
approximation of what happens when you take neurons communicating downstream
and process inputs to the neurons. It seems like and exploding field with a
lot of potential to answer questions like capacity and processing speed. If
one uses neural networks as a model, there are some things one can infer about
a brain. The brain probably does not store information as directly and
accurately as a computer. The more neurons one trains to recognize an input,
the more accurately they can recognize this input (to a limit). A brain
includes a very robust and flexible input system, this means that a brain has
to do a lot more with any one input that a computer usually needs to since any
one input is a lot more complicated than a byte. Most everyday stimuli/inputs
to the are fairly complex and the brain uses a fair amount of capacity to
decipher it accurately. In contrast computer input is relatively discrete and
simple. So a computer can afford the luxury of responding with precisely
accurate output.
NEWTON is an electronic community for Science, Math, and Computer Science K-12 Educators.
Argonne National Laboratory, Division of Educational Programs, Harold Myron, Ph.D., Division Director.