

Black holes and Hadrons
Name: N/A
Status: N/A
Age: N/A
Location: N/A
Country: N/A
Date: 1991
Question:
I have a student with questions that I cannot always answer.
Please help me with the following (my student is 13 and in middle school.
question 1We say that a system which is bound by the nuclear force is le
less massive due to the absence of the energy required to "separate"
the system. An analogue can seemingly be made with the gravitational
force, in that a gravitationally bound system should possess a
smaller mass thanits (unbound) constituents. (this effect would, of course
be minute in everyday circumstances, due to the weak relative strength of f
the gravitational interaction, however in a case such as two black holes
in orbit, the effect should become notable.) We must also, however take
into account the added energy (and thereby mass) of the force itself, which
of course, increases, as does the binding energy, as the system becomes
more strongly bound. Which effect takes precedence; i.e. is the overall m
mass of a gravitationally bound system less than, greater than, or
approximately equal to the mass of its unbound constituents?
Replies:
When two objects that attract one another (whether by
gravitation or anything else) are far apart, let us suppose
they are not moving, so the total energy is basically given
by the sum of the two masses (multiplied by c^2). If they
start moving they gain kinetic energy and the mass goes up.
Suppose we just let them gradually accelerate towards one
another from a long distance away. The total energy should
remain constant (except for radiation effects  if they
are charged they will radiate electromagnetically, and there
will also be gravitational radiation). That is, the kinetic
energy at any time is just equal to the lowering of the energy
due to the attractive interaction at that distance. So
the mass of the system considered as a whole (two objects moving
towards each other), stays constant, because the energy is constant.
If radiation is included, the radiated energy goes off in
all directions, and so the system has lost that energy  ie.
the total energy goes down. Eventually, if the two objects
combine in a "bound state" they are close together and not
moving fast, so their total energy is lowered relative to the original
sum of the masses, and that energy must have disappeared in some form
of radiation.
Click here to return to the Physics Archives
 
Update: June 2012

