Department of Energy Argonne National Laboratory Office of Science NEWTON's Homepage NEWTON's Homepage
NEWTON, Ask A Scientist!
NEWTON Home Page NEWTON Teachers Visit Our Archives Ask A Question How To Ask A Question Question of the Week Our Expert Scientists Volunteer at NEWTON! Frequently Asked Questions Referencing NEWTON About NEWTON About Ask A Scientist Education At Argonne Static and Moving Electric Fields
Name: Jake
Status: student
Age: N/A
Location: N/A
Country: N/A
Date: N/A


Question:
When an electron is static, it has an electrostatic field. When it is put in motion, there is a current making an electromagnetic field. How soon does a electrostatic field change to an electromagnetic field and back? Does it change automatically as soon as it moves OR proportionally to the acceleration of the electron (as the electric field diminishes, the magnetic field grows in respect to the acceleration of the electron)?



Replies:
Samantha,

It does not really change from one to the other, because the field observed depends on the relative motion of the charged particle and an observer. Think of a stationary charged particle viewed by two observers, one moving and one stationary. The moving observer will see an electromagnetic field; the stationary observer will see an electrostatic field.

Here is an analogy: If you look at a piece of paper edge on, it looks like a line segment. But if you change the angle of the paper, or if you move around it, you will notice that the paper has a width as well as a length. The same kind of thing is going on with charged particles, but it is the relative speed, rather than the relative angle, that makes the difference.

--
Tim Mooney


Technically speaking, there is no such thing as a static electron--it will always be traveling at (or very close to) the speed of light. So in a situation where a circuit is turned on and off, there will be cohesive movement in one direction of the electrons. It is the movement of the electrons all in one direction that generates the magnetic field. So how quickly does it take the electrons to start moving in the same direction. I do not know if there have been experiments that have tried to measure this time, but my guess would be something very close to the speed of light. As far as automatically or proportionally, you have to ask yourself to what degree of certainty do you need this answer. The speed of light is increadibly fast, so whether it is proportional or instantaniously, it would be very difficult to tell. Figure it this way, even if the switch is proportional, it would be proportional to such a very large number that by assuming it is proportional or instantaniously and being wrong, you error would be very very small.

Matt Voss


Hello Jake,

You have asked a great question! Seriously!

There are several subtleties that occur here, but I will attempt to give you a concise answer first.

The short answer: The change radiates out at the speed of light.

Now to explain that...

The first thing to keep in mind (and this is not nessecarilly an easy thing to consider!) is that you have got to talk about where you are relative to the electron and what motions are involved.

To keep things simple, let us assume that you are near the electron, and both of you are sitting still. And, suppose you have got a device that measures both electric fields and one that measures magnetic fields too.

When you are both sitting still, all you measure is a reading of the electric field of the electron. Once the electron begins moving relative to you, then things can start changing.

The first question is: How fast does it change? Is it instantaneous, does it lag, what is going on?

The answer is that it depends upon how far you are from the electron(and let us assume things are not moving super fast). The change in the electric field(and the manifestation of the magnetic field) will radiate out from the electron at the speed of light. Therefore, if you are close it will appear possibly very quickly. However, if you are far away, then even after the electron has begun moving(as measured by someone close to the electron), you will not see any change in the electric field or in the position of the electron until after enough time has passed for the variation in the electric field to reach you.

Now, from the language above, you may have figured out that my answer is leaving out much. And it is true!

Electric fields and magnetic fields are related in a very intimate way. Depending upon where you are and how the electron is moving relative to you, electric fields and magnetic fields can be interchanged. That is another way of saying that they manifest themselves from the same thing and that your observation will depend upon your perspective relative to the electron.

So, now let us assume that your electron is moving past you with a constant velocity in a straight line. You will now measure both an electric field and a magnetic field and both of them will change with time.

Now contrast that with the same situation in which you AND the electron are moving parrallel to each other with the same constant velocity. Now, even though I might say that there is an electric and magnetic field and that they are both changing, you would only measure a constant electric field. In other words, so long as your constant motion is the same as that of the electron, it appears to be standing still and so you will only measure an electric field.

There are huge jumping off points here. I have used the word "relative" quite a bit while attempting to avoid "special relativity" However, the honest truth is that you cannot escape it! It was a very similar line of questions that led Einstein to discover special relativity . in fact, Einstein's paper was not called "Special Relativity" or anything like that, but instead "A paper on the electrodynamics of moving bodies."

I would suggest looking up some material on special relativity if you feel interested.

best,

Michael S. Pierce
Materials Science Division
Argonne National Laboratory


Jake,

When talking about individual electrons, we must actually use quantum physics. The photons randomly emitted due to the temperature of the electron are electromagnetic at all times. An electron is always vibrating. When vibrating but not going anywhere, these photons combine into a wave. When we see this wave, it produces an AVERAGE magnetic field of zero but a noticeable electric field.

When the electron is moving, the AVERAGE magnetic field is just as noticeable. The electron absorbs energy from the warm air around it, perhaps even from the equipment used to measure the electron. This heat energy is in turn emitted as electromagnetic waves. Exactly when cannot be measured. There is no exact time of emission. Multiply the energy in the wave. Rest assured that, usually, it is emitted in a time that is on the order of billionths of a second or shorter.

When you get into quantum mechanics, often a college course, you will learn how individual particles work very different from groups of particles. In a physics class that has not reached quantum theory, individual electrons are treated the same as larger charges to make the work easier. You can spend more time understanding electric and magnetic fields now. When you have had the preparation everyone needs (calculus, electromagnetic theory, light,...), a professor can tell you the wonders of how individual particles seem to behave.

God bless you,
Dr. Mellendorf



Click here to return to the Physics Archives

NEWTON is an electronic community for Science, Math, and Computer Science K-12 Educators, sponsored and operated by Argonne National Laboratory's Educational Programs, Andrew Skipor, Ph.D., Head of Educational Programs.

For assistance with NEWTON contact a System Operator (help@newton.dep.anl.gov), or at Argonne's Educational Programs

NEWTON AND ASK A SCIENTIST
Educational Programs
Building 360
9700 S. Cass Ave.
Argonne, Illinois
60439-4845, USA
Update: June 2012
Weclome To Newton

Argonne National Laboratory