Department of Energy Argonne National Laboratory Office of Science NEWTON's Homepage NEWTON's Homepage
NEWTON, Ask A Scientist!
NEWTON Home Page NEWTON Teachers Visit Our Archives Ask A Question How To Ask A Question Question of the Week Our Expert Scientists Volunteer at NEWTON! Frequently Asked Questions Referencing NEWTON About NEWTON About Ask A Scientist Education At Argonne Optical Density Determination
Name: Theresa A.
Status: educator
Grade: 9-12
Location: N/A
Country: N/A
Date: 1/24/2005


Question:
Why does light pass through some pure substances, but not others (eg. diamond vs graphite ... both are Carbon)? On a molecular level, what exactly determines optical density (it is not the same as mass density)? Why does light slow down in optically dense media?


Replies:
Theresa-

There are at least two kinds of "optical density", maybe more like three:

1) absorbance (it is clear, but it is to some degree dark, like smoky glass. Light is diminishing as it travels through.)

2) refractive index (it is clear, but light goes slower through it. So it changes direction at surfaces. for large index, some of the light bounces off each surface. Metallic reflection is an extreme case of this.)

3) scattering density ( it is clear but messy with refractive index surfaces, so it becomes cluttered or frosty or milky or white)

Any given substance has some amount of each of these three "densities".

Only refractive index has any connection with mass density. That being: heavy substances are made of high-atomic-number elements, which have many electrons, which cause higher refractive index. High concentrations of bound electrons (bound in one place, but elastically movable by a short distance) are the "water" that slows down the flight of light.

Viscously-movable electrons absorb light (1) at all wavelengths. This is graphite black, and it enforces the opacity of metals. You can see through metals if they are less than 0.1 micrometer thick. One-way mirrors are this. But if thicker, the part of light which is not reflected at the front surface will be completely absorbed. Metallic opacity.

Light is also absorbed by bound electrons using the energy to climb out of their trapped state, or at least climb to a higher trapped state. But it has to be the right amount of energy, so it is a more color-selective absorption. It creates most of the non-neutral colors of objects.

Chemical purity helps a clear substance be clearer, but it cannot help an inherently absorbing substance like graphite become clear. Perfect single crystals of graphite are a lighter silvery color than typical poly-crystalline graphite. Certain impurities in graphite actually donate more mobile electrons, which sometimes make it lighter still.

Chemically pure glass is silicon dioxide. Light can go for tens to thousands of meters in this, depending on color, if it is pure. Give it unnecessary surfaces by grinding it up, and you have sand: more white than clear. Chemically pure aluminum oxide can be white if it is many small crystallites, or clear if it is one large crystal (colorless sapphire). Pure water is not a crystal, it is random inside, but it can be clear in a uniform mass, or milky if dispersed as fog. Ice can be either clear or cloudy or fractured with flaws.

Diamond vs Graphite:

The carbon atom can make 4 chemical bonds (shared-electron-links) to its neighbors. In diamond, each atom links to 4 different neighbors, and every electron is bound (confined) within its own link. So there are no mobile electrons, and diamond is a dielectric not a conductor, and it is clear, not absorbing. In graphite, each atom links to only 3 neighbors, making a flat sheet, and each has one link left over. All these leftover links are shared in common by the whole sheet. The electrons of this pool of links are mobile, so graphite conducts electricity and absorbs light. There are not many elements which have a choice of whether or not to be conductive.

Those are the classical optical properties. Iridescence and dichroism are a different story.

Jim Swenson


If a substance has an unoccupied electronic state whose energy difference from initial state is the same as the energy of the incident radiation (light), and given certain other restriction, then the substance will absorb the incident radiation. The electronic structure of the substance determines whether or not such unoccupied but accessible electronic states exist; however, the details of determining such states is rather involved. The bonding in diamond and graphite is a good example. Both are carbon, but in diamond the carbon atoms are bonded to one another by single bonds and these electrons do not respond to visible light. The electronic structure of graphite on the other hand is stacks of sheets of carbon in which the electrons are highly delocalized in such a way that essentially all visible light is absorbed. As a result graphite is black.

The measure of the ratio of the transmitted power, Ptrans. (energy / sec) to the incident power, Pincid.: Ptrans. / Pincid. = Tr is called the transmittance (or in the older literature the transmission). This ratio has a range: 0 < Tr < 1 but it can vary over a wide range of values, for example: Tr = 10^-1 or Tr = 10^-5 even though it is a number between 0 and 1. The optical density: O.D. is defined as: O.D. = log10( 1/ Tr) = - log10(Tr). The reason for using this "log10" scale is to make the numbers positive and to make their range smaller since the O.D. in the power of 10 in the exponent. Despite the use of the same term "density" O.D. has nothing directly to do with the mass density.

Your second question, Why light slows down in a medium is more subtle and involved. It is equivalent to the question of why transparent substances have an index of refraction. The index of refraction, 'n' is: n = 1 + (electronic term) where the (electronic term) involves a ratio that involves the charge density of the medium in the numerator and the electron mass and the frequency of light in the denominator. What is going on is that the incident light "tries to cause" the electrons in the medium to vibrate at the same frequency as the incident light, but when the electron moves its neighboring electrons sense this induced change in the first electron and respond to try to "pull the electron back into its equilibrium position". This "pulling back" causes the oscillation of the initial electron to "slow down". Which, in effect means the speed of the oscillation is retarded -- that is the speed of propagation of light is slowed. This is a very approximate description of what is happening.

For more details you can refer to Richard Feynman's "Lectures on Physics" Vol. 1, Chapter 31, "The Origin of the Refractive Index".

Vince Calder



Click here to return to the Physics Archives

NEWTON is an electronic community for Science, Math, and Computer Science K-12 Educators, sponsored and operated by Argonne National Laboratory's Educational Programs, Andrew Skipor, Ph.D., Head of Educational Programs.

For assistance with NEWTON contact a System Operator (help@newton.dep.anl.gov), or at Argonne's Educational Programs

NEWTON AND ASK A SCIENTIST
Educational Programs
Building 360
9700 S. Cass Ave.
Argonne, Illinois
60439-4845, USA
Update: June 2012
Weclome To Newton

Argonne National Laboratory