Department of Energy Argonne National Laboratory Office of Science NEWTON's Homepage NEWTON's Homepage
NEWTON, Ask A Scientist!
NEWTON Home Page NEWTON Teachers Visit Our Archives Ask A Question How To Ask A Question Question of the Week Our Expert Scientists Volunteer at NEWTON! Frequently Asked Questions Referencing NEWTON About NEWTON About Ask A Scientist Education At Argonne Mass Concept
Name: B Hope
Status: educator
Age: 30s
Location: N/A
Country: N/A
Date: 9/6/2004


Question:
One of my 11th grade students is having a really tough time with the concept of mass. Any suggestions? How can I go about giving her the simplest of explanations and clear it up for her. She thinks the definitions for Mass and matter are circular. Mass is the amount of matter in something and matter is anything with mass....


Replies:
Your student is very perceptive and is to be congratulated for recognizing the circularity of the terms mass and matter, in most texts and references the two definitions ARE CIRCULAR. Van Nostrand's Scientific Encyclopedia defines "mass" as: " The physical measure of the principal inertial property of a body, i.e., its resistance to change of motion." It continues: " Under these circumstances [speeds small compared to the speed of light], the masses M1 and M2 of two bodies may be compared by allowing the two bodies to interact [whatever that means]. Then M1/M2 = |a1|/|a2| where |a1| and |a2| are the magnitudes of the respective accelerations of the two bodies as a result of the interaction." The two citations below are equally useless [that is a value judgment on my part].

http://www.wordiq.com/definition/Matter

http://www.wordiq.com/definition/Mass

What is glossed over in physics is that there are certain terms in the theory that cannot be defined within the system itself. "Matter" (or mass) is one of these. As you see from above there are logical difficulties because the definition introduces an undefined term "interact". Such theories are called "effective theories" because we study the "effects" of these undefined terms. Geometry provides an example. In plane geometry we study the behavior of points and lines, but these terms are not defined within the subject itself. They are the "undefined" terms whose relations to one another is the subject matter of geometry. If we introduce the concept of real number plane, we can define a point as an ordered pair of real numbers (X,Y), which gets us out of trouble with the definition of "point" only to introduce other undefined terms. For example what is the definition of "number"? Similarly, within the context of real numbers "i", the square root of (-1), is undefined. This only becomes defined when the theory of complex numbers is introduced.

In my opinion we must grasp that within any description of nature there are going to be certain fundamental terms that are undefined within the system. This is also related to Goedel's incompleteness theorem.

Vince Calder


B.

They really are not circular, but as you have indicated below, you can use one to describe the other.

In our macro universe, and I am not going into quantum mechanics here, Matter is a term used to describe a collection of molecules/atoms which make up objects. We have either matter or energy (which of course are interrelated). When we generally speak of matter, that matter has a property called Mass. Mass is different then weight. Mass is a constant that remains with that object and has some control over how that object reacts in the universe.

Bob Hartwell


Mass and matter are completely different concepts. Matter is anything that can be touched -- that takes up space and is distinguishable from empty space. Matter is just another word for "stuff". Mass is a property of matter -- one of many properties, including color, shape, and charge.

Mass is the property of matter that defines what force a piece of matter feels when it's in a gravitational field (i.e., near some other thing that has mass), and how strong a gravitational field the piece of matter generates. (Similarly, charge defines what force a piece of matter feels from an electromagnetic field, and how strong an electromagnetic field it generates.)

But mass also defines what an object does when any force acts on it. Exactly the same property tells you two completely different things:

1) what gravitational force there is on a object, and

2) how that object responds to (is accelerated by) forces of any kind.

I don't think anybody understands why, and people have gone nuts trying to measure any difference between (1) and (2).

Tim Mooney


B. Hope H.,

Mass is a measurement, a measure of how much matter there is. Volume is also a measure of how much matter there is, but a different kind of measure. An example is groceries. Some groceries have volume on the package. Some groceries have how much mass. Both tell you how much material you are buying.

Matter is a state of existence. Some things in the universe qualify as matter. Some qualify as waves. When you get down to super-tiny scales, i.e. quantum physics, matter and waves start to merge. Things begin to have both matter and wave properties at the same time. On an everyday scale, matter interacts according to Newtonian physics. Waves interact according to different laws. Energy of matter is in the mass and speed. Energy of a wave is in the frequency. Matter is made of particles (quarks and leptons). Waves are not. A wave can be made of photons, e.g. microwaves. A wave can be made of the motion of matter, e.g. sound.

Dr. Ken Mellendorf
Physics Instructor
Illinois Central College


Dear B Hope,

This is a common misconception that many students (and former students) have trouble with -- mass and matter are different (but related) concepts, and mass and weight are different (but related) concepts.

So, start with a definition of matter. Matter is anything that takes up space (has volume) and has mass. So here are some examples of matter: rocks (solid), water (liquid), air (gas), your desk, your arm, your shoe. Now students seem convinced that everything (even the air!!) is matter. So, what are some things that are NOT matter (things that do not take up space and do not have mass)? Here are some "non-matter" things to get you started: heat, light, an idea. These are things that are NOT matter.

Because of its definition, matter has four general properties, that is, four quantities that can always be assigned to something that is matter: mass, weight, volume, and density. Mass and weight are different, but related quantities. An object's mass is a measure of its inertia -- the more mass an object has, the more resistant it is to changes in motion. So a big rock has more mass than a small rock. The big rock also weighs more than the little rock in the earth's gravitational field. If you took both rocks way into the universe, outside of any gravitational field, both rocks would not have any weight -- but the big rock would still be more resistant to a change in motion than the little rock -- that is, the big rock still has more mass than the little rock, even though both rocks are "weightless".

In the metric system, weight and mass are designated with different units. An object's weight is a measure of the force of gravity acting on the object, measured in Newtons. An object's mass is a measure of its resistance to inertia, measured in kilograms. Let us say that an object has a weight of about 60 Newtons (about 13.5 pounds) on the earth. Its mass would be about 6 kilograms. If you took that object to the surface of the moon, where the gravitational is less, its weight would now be about 10 Newtons (about 2.25 pounds), but its mass is still 6 kilograms.

I hope this helps. The key point is that mass is a property of matter; by definition, anything that is matter has mass and takes up space. The property of mass is the object's resistance to changes in motion (its inertia). The greater the quantity of matter, the more inertia (hence, more mass) it has.

Todd Clark, Office of Science
U.S. Department of Energy


Matter can be held.

Mass is a measure of the amount of matter.

Greg Bradburn



Click here to return to the Physics Archives

NEWTON is an electronic community for Science, Math, and Computer Science K-12 Educators, sponsored and operated by Argonne National Laboratory's Educational Programs, Andrew Skipor, Ph.D., Head of Educational Programs.

For assistance with NEWTON contact a System Operator (help@newton.dep.anl.gov), or at Argonne's Educational Programs

NEWTON AND ASK A SCIENTIST
Educational Programs
Building 360
9700 S. Cass Ave.
Argonne, Illinois
60439-4845, USA
Update: June 2012
Weclome To Newton

Argonne National Laboratory