

Fish Size in Water
Name: Laura L.
Status: other
Age: 40s
Location: N/A
Country: N/A
Date: 7/17/2003
Question:
I was kayaking the other day and saw a rather large fish in no more than 2 1/2 ft
of water. My question is would the water magnify the size of the fish or are things only
magnified underwater while wearing a mask. If the water does magnify things at that depth
how much larger would they appear. I do not want to be telling any untrue fish tales!
Replies:
Interesting question: the usual question is how deep does an object underwater appear.
(the answer is 3/4 of its actual depth; an object four feet underwater appears to be 3 feet
underwater, using the index of refraction of water to be 4/3).
To answer your question, though, look straight down at one end of the fish from a height h
above the water and at an angle a with a line perpendicular to the surface of the water at
the other end of the fish, which is at a depth d underwater. A ray of light refracts at the
water's surface to an angle b with the perpendicular where sin a = n sin b, where n=4/3 is the
index of refraction of the water. If
you know a little trigonometry and draw a diagram as I described, I am sure you can obtain:
w = (h + d) tan a,
s = h tan a + d tan b,
m = w/s = ((h+d) tan a)/(h tan a + d tan b)
Here w is the apparent length of the fish, s is the actual length and m is the magnification.
Using the approximation sin a = a (accurate at small angles, but good to 2% even at 20 degrees):
m = n(h+d)/(nh+d)
Notice that if the fish is at the surface (d=0), the magnification is 1 and
the fish is seen unmagnified.
At d = h, m = 2n/(n+1).
Using n = 4/3, this gives m=8/7.
But wait!!! The fish looks closer to the surface than it is and so you observe the fish to be
3/4 * 8/7 = 6/7 of its actual size if you correct for it seeming to be closer and therefore
larger than it actually is! At any rate, it looks somewhere between 6/7 and 8/7 of its actual
size, so you are not exaggerating that much (unless you are truly exaggerating!)
I hope this is clear, but I certainly find it confusing... If you would like more words from
me, feel free to write again.
Best, Dick Plano, Professor of Physics emeritus, Rutgers University
Click here to return to the Physics Archives
 
Update: June 2012

