Name: Doug A.
Is it possible to store a large number of Protons in a container?
For example, if one stripped, say 1 mol of hydrogen atoms, could they be
stored in a container of some sort? Like a sealed electrostatic cylinder
Note that this produces about 96000 Coulombs of charge, which could also
be a problem...
I cannot say such a thing is impossible, but let us first consider the amount
of force the container would have to exert. For simplicity, treat it as two
half-moles, each with a charge of 48000 Coulombs, at a distance of about 1
meter. The force between these two charges, using Coulomb's law is about
2x10^19 Newtons, or close to 4x10^18 pounds. That is a huge amount of
force. Imagine what would happen if the container couldn't hold. What do
you think would happen to the container? It might explode. Electric force
is a VERY STRONG force when the charge amounts get significantly large.
Another problem is keeping individual protons within a container. Most
solid materials would allow many of the protons to pass through. Some would
grab an electron, coming through as a hydrogen molecule. Some protons would
join with atoms of the container, changing the elements the container is
made of. Many electrons would be drawn into the container, pairing with the
protons you still had. You would need something that pushed protons into
the center of the container, but pushed electrons outside the container.
The only way to store protons successfully that I am aware of is magnetic.
Fast-moving charged particles in a strong magnetic field tend to move in a
circle around the field. Nobody knows why magnetic force acts this way, but
many particle physicists are grateful for it.
Storage rings can be used for any charged particles, but the most common are
electrons, anti-electrons (or positrons), and protons. Their big downfall
is they cannot be used for neutrons. Since neutrons have zero charge,
magnetic fields will not hold them.
Dr. Ken Mellendorf
Illinois Central College
I am sure that protons can be stored, but to my knowledge, you cannot "put
them in a bottle".
They would be stored in a synchrotron or other type of particle accelerator.
Here they travel at high speeds in a ring. They are kept "on course, and
focused" by electric and magnetic fields.
Do a search on www.google.com on the terms: particle accelerator,
Click here to return to the Physics Archives
Update: June 2012