

Measuring Buoyancy
Name: Marie
Status: educator
Grade: 912
Location: MO
Date: November 2007
Question:
I have a student who would like to do a science fair project testing
the effect of shape of an object on buoyancy. She wants to take equal blocks of
clay and form them into several shapes and test buoyancy. My question is "How
would she measure buoyancy?
Replies:
If I were to do this science fair project I would place a hook on each object to
be measured. Hang it from a spring balance and read the number in and out of
the water. The difference would be caused by the buoyancy effect.
It might be interesting to do the experiment in fresh water and then in salt
water. It could be tied to the difference in how low in the water (the draft) a
ship floats in the ocean and in fresh water like the Great Lakes or the
Mississippi River.
Larry Krengel
Buoyancy is basically measured as a difference. It is the difference in
an object's weight when it is in different surroundings. So if your
student has the clay blocks in water, she'd need to measure the weight
of the object in water and out of water.
Remember when an object is floating on water, its "weight" is zero; if
it is underwater and would rise if released, its weight is negative.
Richard Barrans, Ph.D., M.Ed.
Department of Physics and Astronomy
University of Wyoming
The simplest way would be to load each model with weights until it sank
or was completely under water. She also needs to be sure that each
"hull" weighs exactly the same amount.
Robert Avakian
DEFINITION: Buoyancy is the force (that is weight) of a fluid displaced by
an object immersed in that fluid. The most common fluid used for such
measurements is water, since 1 gm. of water occupies about 1 cc. at room
temperature. You can find the "exact" value in any handbook or web site
tabulation of the density of water as a function of temperature. If the
weight of the volume of the fluid (water) is less than the weight of the
object, it will "sink". In such cases the buoyancy can be measured by just
weighing the object immersed in the fluid (water). The weight loss, compared
to the weight of the object in air, which can be taken as negligible weight
loss, is the buoyancy force.
For simple shapes where the volume can be calculated from the formula for
volume for that shape, it is only necessary to compute the volume of the
object without doing any weighings. Things get experimentally trickier if
the shape of the object is such that the weight of the displaced fluid (water)
equals the weight of the object when the object is only partially submerged.
In such cases, the object will partially float. The system coming "to rest"
when the weight of the displaced volume of fluid equals the weight of the part
of the object that is immersed under the fluid (water). The most common example
is of course an ice cube in water. Since the density of ice is about 90% that of
liquid water, the ice cube will "sink" leaving about 10% of the ice cube above
the water level.
The selection of clay (density much greater than water) as the construction
material makes things simpler. Weigh the object suspended in air. Then weigh
the object suspended in the fluid (water). That difference (weight loss) is
the weight of the displaced fluid (water). Since the density of water is 1 gm
per cubic centimeter, that is numerically the same as volume of displaced fluid
(water).
With some care it should be possible to make both a solid sphere and a hollow
sphere of the same size. You will then see the much greater buoyancy of the hollow
sphere compared to the solid sphere, even though from the "outside" both objects
appear to have the same size (that is, volume). You can also make a torus of the
same amount of clay and be able to experimentally measure the volume of a torus
compared to that of a sphere that weighs the same (in air). The key to keeping
things simple is to be sure the difference in the shapes is always large enough
for the object to completely "sink" rather than partially float. In such cases,
even how you "float" the object will change the result since the amount of
displaced fluid (water) will depend upon the orientation of the same object.
Yet another variation would be to change the fluid from water to some other
fluid. Then the change in the apparent weight in the new fluid compared to
the weight loss suspended in water measures the density of the new fluid compared
to water. A concentrated solution of some very soluble salt like
Mg(SO4) (Epsom's salt) will measure the density of the solution. You could even
dilute the salt solution with water and measure the density as a function of
concentration.
Vince Calder
Click here to return to the General Topics Archives
 
Update: June 2012

