

Force of Wind on Building
Name: Evie
Status: student
Grade: 912
Location: LA
Country: USA
Date: Summer 2011
Question:
How could you quantify and analyze the force of wind on a high rise building?
Replies:
With some difficulty! The force depends upon the details of the
shape of the building, in all three directions. In addition, the force
depends upon the wind profile, also in all three directions. In addition,
there can be torques (twisting motions). There can also be resonances if
the building and the wind interact with one another. While building
engineers have to do these kinds of computations, they are neither simple
nor easy.
Vince Calder
Hi Evie,
Manually calculating wind loading on a building (or any object) is an
extremely complex and difficult task, and the results are usually not
very accurate. These days, this task is accomplished using Finite
Element Analysis (FEA) software running on a very fast computer. The
results are quite accurate, but highly computationintensive. This type
of software does an initial calculation, then the answer is used to
refine the next iteration of calculations. This is commonly repeated
hundreds of times until the results converge on a solution that no
longer changes with each repetition. Even on a fast computer, it can
take many hours of calculations before the results converge on a solution.
To use this type of FEA software, a CAD model is first created using 3D
modeling software such as SolidWorks, ProEngineer, or similar
engineering software. Then the file containing the 3D computer model is
fed into the FEA software referred to above. The results are
impressively accurate.... vastly more accurate than is possible with
manual calculations.
Regards,
Bob Wilson.
It is very difficult to actually measure the wind forces on a fullsize
high rise. Wind forces push and twist the entire building.
A good measure of total wind forces can be obtained by putting force
sensors on the outside walls that measure the wind pressure, and add up
the measurements. Better accuracy is obtained when there is more force
sensors.
A direct, but less practical way to determine the wind forces on the
building is to first measure how far the building deflects (inches or
fractions of an inch) in the wind, measured by sensitive instruments.
If one knows mathematically the relationship between force and
deflection then one can calculate the force, but this forcedeflection
relationship is also not easy to figure out either.
Because of the difficulty in instrumenting an actual building, many
researchers use miniature model buildings (a few feet tall). The
miniature models are put into a wind tunnel for testing, where the
wind can be controlled very well. These models have force sensors
built into them and a lot can be learned this way. The only drawback
to this method is that complicating effects (gusts, terrain, etc) on
the smaller model may not exactly duplicate in miniature the wind
forces on the full size building.
A fourth way to analyze the force on a building is to do a
mathematical calculation on a computer. The science behind these
calculations is quite well established, and accurate results can be obtained.
It is good to verify the computer model using a miniature model in a
wind tunnel, and best of all it is good to check these analyses using a
real building.
Robert Erck
Click here to return to the Engineering Archives
 
Update: June 2012

