Ask A Scientist© Biology Archive

Question:  If a tissue donor dies and some of his/her tissue is donated, 
should the family be given money or some other benefit?  I am a freshman 
at York HS and am doing a bioethics project.
Betty A Laliberte

Answer:
An interesting question.  In my opinion, a family should not receive
payment for organ donation.  That would introduce an economic element
into the decision, which does not seem appropriate.  One problem is:
Who will pay?  The recipient?  What if he can't afford it?  Who gets the 
organ?  The highest bidder?  I guess part of my problem with selling 
organs and tissues is religious in nature.  To me, my life and my body 
were given freely to me and they are not mine to sell to someone else.  
They certainly do not belong to my family to profit from.
Brian Schwartz